I hated pampers newborn (size 1), they didn't make a good seal round the legs so pee leaked straight out.
She was small though, (6lb 11oz BW) so maybe that's why, but Huggies size 1s fit well and didn't leak, so personally I'd go with huggies over pampers.
This time I'm doing cloth from the start so have 6 prefolds in tiny baby size (4-9lb), 3 newborn Grovia (up to 12lb), and an assortment of other cloth nappies, in either first size (7-18lb) or birth-potty (approx 8lb-35lb!)
I'm going to see the cloth nappy library person though as you can hire out a kit with everything you need, so I'm going to arrange to hire some tiny newborn size nappies (up to 8/9lb or so) starting maybe a few weeks before I'm due, so I have them ready. Then if the baby is bigger than expected or soon reaches that weight I will exchange it for a smaller kit of nappies that are size 1 or birth-potty (as I should have almost enough of those, will probably only need to borrow about 8 at most, it's just the newborn stage I might struggle with if the baby is small like my other two were as birth-potty nappies don't give a good fit on tiny newborns under 8/9lb).