Reusable vs disposable nappies??

Meg86

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
178
Reaction score
0
Hi,

Can anyone offer any advice on nappies please? I think we've decided to try and use reusable nappies as much as we can but use disposable ones when we're out and about. I really have no idea where to start though! Can anyone offer any advice please?

Mx
 
I was an environmental scientist at university and we did a study on this. Environmentally speaking they are both as bad as each other. The reusables cost the earth in water, energy to heat the water, chemicals to clean them. The disposables are obvious why they aren’t great.
The biggest difference is cost. The reusables have a bigger up front cost but if you use them for future children too then you save yourself a ton of money!
 
with my first i was all "We'll go reusable!" and it cost a FORTUNE to wash and dry them constantly.

now i get supercheap aldi or lidl ones.
 
I'm currently debating this. I think I will go with reusable ones to save on landfill, we do as a species have a lot of waste already and will possibly look into buying second hand ones as well to save on the upfront costs. We will also try to dry them in conservatory over summer or on the line and possibly in front of fire over winter when it's on. To save using tumble drier too much.
Plus disposables have chemicals in which i'd rather avoid putting next to my baby's skin.

But it is still something i'm looking into at present.
 
Fill in the questionnaire on the nappy lady website, I found her really helpful.
 
I cloth nappied my two and honestly I never noticed my energy bills going up at all. With a newborn you wash a lot anyway. It was one extra wash every two days...
 
For those of you that have used cloth nappies is there a style or brand you recommend? Mx
 
I would advise going to The Nappy Lady website - its amazing and full of really useful information, she has a questionnaire you complete and she lets you know what you do and don't need. Also she has a group on facebook which is really handy and I've picked up loads of useful info.

I am adamant I will only use cloth nappies; have been since I found out I was pregnant. I have slowly built up my little stash of items, and you can get some real bargains (ebay, fb selling groups) which cuts down the outlay cost.

I'm a bit upset by the first comment on this; I'm a conservation biologist and the statement 'Environmentally speaking they are both as bad as each other' is simply not true at all. In 2004 a report was released that stated something similar. However; in 2008 a revised report was released stating the original report was flawed and the data was based on outdated nappies and techniques. It is consumers' behaviour after purchase that determines most of the impacts from reusable nappies. Most nappies can be washed at 40 (unless really bad), Don't tumble dry simple (the are better line dried or in direct sunlight anyway), ensure you always have enough in your washer as a full load. Most of the time an EcoEgg can be used for washing, so no harsh chemicals at all.

Yes they are cheaper in the long run, but that isn't the only benefit at all. it is better for your babies skin and better for the environment.
 
I would advise going to The Nappy Lady website - its amazing and full of really useful information, she has a questionnaire you complete and she lets you know what you do and don't need. Also she has a group on facebook which is really handy and I've picked up loads of useful info.

I am adamant I will only use cloth nappies; have been since I found out I was pregnant. I have slowly built up my little stash of items, and you can get some real bargains (ebay, fb selling groups) which cuts down the outlay cost.

I'm a bit upset by the first comment on this; I'm a conservation biologist and the statement 'Environmentally speaking they are both as bad as each other' is simply not true at all. In 2004 a report was released that stated something similar. However; in 2008 a revised report was released stating the original report was flawed and the data was based on outdated nappies and techniques. It is consumers' behaviour after purchase that determines most of the impacts from reusable nappies. Most nappies can be washed at 40 (unless really bad), Don't tumble dry simple (the are better line dried or in direct sunlight anyway), ensure you always have enough in your washer as a full load. Most of the time an EcoEgg can be used for washing, so no harsh chemicals at all.

Yes they are cheaper in the long run, but that isn't the only benefit at all. it is better for your babies skin and better for the environment.

No need to be upset. Here’s a report from 2008... https://www.gov.uk/government/uploa...achment_data/file/291130/scho0808boir-e-e.pdf
Says pretty much what I did but obviously you can change your impact with reusables with how you wash/dry them. I imagine those who choose reusables for the environmental impact will wash/dry them in a mindful way.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
473,596
Messages
4,653,911
Members
110,081
Latest member
monicurka
Back
Top