Apologies if I'm treading on someone else's toes as I didn't read all posts... but I swear by waterwipes . Basically not really had nappy rash since the first couple.yes they are overpriced but it's essentially like using cotton wool and water with all the practicality of a wipe and none of the chemicals and they don't fall apart .. They are 99.9% water and 0.1% fruit extract ( wish I'd invented them the profit margin must be huge!) However I buy them in bulk off amazon to make it cheaper approx £20 for like a wholesale box x