I'm the same, I like names that aren't too out there as in they don't sound made up, but nothing too commonly used!
My son is called Caleb, I love that name and it ticked all the boxes for me. He's two and a half now and I've only heard of two other Calebs, one was much older than mine and one was younger, the name never really took hold!
For this baby I like Reuben for a boy, and we're pretty much set on Zara for a girl.
Hope you find something you like, I hate the name search, for me it's the worst part of being pregnant, it's too much responsibility!