Sounds right to me. He is getting a consequence for not doing as he should but it is a reasonable punishment not a physical one. As long as they understand why they are being punished. That's what was good about my upbringing. I was never smacked or even yelled at. I just had consequences such as not being allowed tv or not having a particular treat but it was always explained to me. So I knew if I didn't tidy my room, I would not be allowed to go out to ride the horse. Etc
Xx
this is my way of thinking...............i like to try and learn my son that if he dont do right then there will be a consequence with out actually getting stressed an avin to fight with him,
i do understand to a point my partners way and if it works for him that is great but its not for me! some times say if we are shopping and my son starts coz he cant av sweets ect then i will just pick him up an put him in car with out gettin stressed an wait till he has calmed down (can take 20 mins) then explain why he is there (for not listening) then when calm again go bk in, its a long process
i think my partner says his kids respect him n know when to stop as they just know with the tone of his voice etc coz he takes no nonsence, both ways i suppose have the same out come but i just prefere my way but my dear OH thinks its far to soft n it just winds me up that instead of thinking like me well there is no wrong way an if she like to do it that way GREAT he gets all opinionated an starts to bicker with me,
as well coz this is his 4th child an my second he thinks he just knows best wich is crud
rant over, this is pretty much whats hes like with every thing pmsl
another example, my mums really ill on an off (hes never seen her at her worst) a few months ago he started sayin i was to soft with my mum and i should burden my self with all her problem ect ect so i simply explained, my mum has nearly died on me twice n im very close to her, im not a mug but i know when my mum needs me weather it be right in your eyes or not ill be there 110% to which he claimed was crap an my mum shouldnt be the way she is n so needy on me, anyway we agreed to dis agree as we always do pmsl,
amonth ago or so he my mum was rushed in hozzy and was very sick, he got to see this for him self an couldnt believe his eyes! anyway a day or two later he come to me an appologyesd sayin he ws so sorry for the not understanding an being more supportive at the time an he know now what i mean and why i am like i am,
its just with every ting its like he cant just trust me as to what i am saying i cant put it in to words what he lacks but it is very very annoying n im hopin will sort its self out with time
sorry for hijacking your post lol an for long reply