American Idol

[Rosie1]

Anyone see american idol on Thursday?!

Jason singing Hallelujiah made the hair on the back of my neck stand up, he is AMAZING

Jason to win! woo!

 

[Tara & Liam]

i watched it but i did like the rock version of "hello" best. Definitely think that a boy is going to win.

and Jason is just getting better and better.

i thought that Asia should have stayed out of the girls and perhaps the oriental girl should have gone. She sang like she was reading off an autocue.

glad that Danny went, really got on my nerves, especially when he said that he wanted people to look up at him, i was like "whatever"

 

[debecca]

I loved "Hello" too.

Think the boys are way better than the girls this year.

Er... not that I watch AI of course

 

[glitzyglamgirl]

I loved "Hello" too.

Think the boys are way better than the girls this year.

Er... not that I watch AI of course

No, me neither

But my favourites so far (in order) are Ickle David, Aussie Micheal, and Dreadlock Jason.

Not really feeling it with any of the girls this year though Carly and Brook are pretty good!

 

[Tara & Liam]

Carly and Brook were great last night.

whatever happened to David, he just couldnt sing last night could he, imagine forgetting his words.

Out of the guys i liked the bloke who sang 'Hello' last week, what is his name.

who do you think will go tonight. i think it should be the bloke who they said over sang.

x

 

[Rosie1]

I want amanda to go...EVERY song sounds the same, no matter what it is. She does shouts it. I think she is trying to be like Pat Bentar (who i like), but not quite pulling it off....

 

[glitzyglamgirl]

I want amanda to go...EVERY song sounds the same, no matter what it is. She does shouts it. I think she is trying to be like Pat Bentar (who i like), but not quite pulling it off....

Couldnt agree more!

She sounds good when she really belts it, but actually trying to "sing" is a disaster shes so tuneless!

Time for her to go!

 

[debecca]

Out of the guys i liked the bloke who sang 'Hello' last week, what is his name.
who do you think will go tonight. i think it should be the bloke who they said over sang.

"Hello" guy is David Cook. I didn't rate him much in the early stages but he's now one of my favourites

I also have a real soft spot for Jason Castro (dreadlocks)... when he talks he's so obviously a complete stoner but he has such a gorgeous demeanour and voice when he sings.

And as for David Hernandez going HURRAY! I've never liked him and I was annoyed cos he has a fairly good voice so I thought he'd be around a good few weeks yet (was convinced Kristy-Lee would be first to go)... as soon as he said he was singing "I Saw Her Standing There" (karaoke hell) I knew he was gone and I was dancing round the room

Er... not that I care or even watch American Idol

 

[Tara & Liam]

Top 4 are David Cook (thanks for the name). Carly, Brook or Jason. in that order

 

[Rosie1]

so chuffed that amanda went last week, she was really doing my head in. Be gone with the scary stripy trousers!!

Still want Jason to win, although erring towards David Cook now.

Carly - love her voice but made me want to slap her when she started babbling on that "blackbird" is the same as how it is to fail in the music industry. Maybe i'm too harsh?! can't be doing with all the sentimental BS they come out with, always feels like they're going for the sympathy vote.

Wonder what the theme will be this week - ooh i lOVE American Idol!

 

[Tara & Liam]

I am so sad, googled AI then read up all about past contestants. how sad am i.

 

[claire2711]

noo!!! ramielle (the teeny tiny one) got kicked off!! i loved her! she has a brill voice

 

[debecca]

Yeah but Ramielle didn't really seem to *care* at all the last few weeks, she had definitely lost her sparkle. I don't think it helps that votefortheworst.com are supporting Kristy-Lee Cook either because it means she's getting more votes than she should and so keeps coming second to bottom.

I thought it was a fair bottom three on Friday - I predicted it correctly anyway. I'm hoping the final will be between David Cook, David Archuleta and Michael Johns.

 

[Rosie1]

have to say i'm glad ramielle went this week.

She annoyed me with the way she became so mousy and shy and girly whenever anyone spoke to her, yet in the audition stages and hollywood week she was nothing like that. I don't think her voice was up to it either really.

Next to go should be either Kristy Lee or Saiesha (sp?).

David cook looking quite hot with his new hair cut!

 

[debecca]

I think I'm going to cry.

HOW did Michael Johns end up eliminated this week when he was one of my favourites and crappy singers like Kristy-Lee get to sing another night?



I almost want to stop watching.

 

[Tara & Liam]

NOOO i havent watched the elimation yet but will be watching it later on today.

Wonder if it is because technically he is an Australian that has emigrated. Carly better look out the too.

 

[debecca]

NOOO i havent watched the elimation yet but will be watching it later on today.

Wonder if it is because technically he is an Australian that has emigrated. Carly better look out the too.

Sorry for ruining the surprise hun

Well I don't think it's because he's Australian... he's managed to avoid the bottom 3 enitrely so far and I think the reason he went this week was a combination of 2 factors:

1. His performance wasn't as good as it has been the last couple of weeks.

2. He was in the "death slot" (went first) - notorious for people leaving before their time, because they are forgotten by the time the vote comes around.

STILL gutted about this. Irrationally so!

 

[debecca]

Seems like I'm the only one still watching

Not AT ALL surprised Carly went last night. Let's think about how the American public are going to react to someone singing "Jesus Christ Superstar" shall we? What a daft choice of song!

It's like the exact opposite of when redneckalicious Kristy-Lee sang "God Bless America" the other week thus guaranteeing her survival!!!

 

[Tara & Liam]

I still want David Cook to win. He is the only one on there that i would consider buying his CD. i did like David Argutella (sp) but his performance leaves me cold. and am i the only one that thinks that his dad looks like the original Starsky from Starsky and Hutch?